Garden Media Guild awards last week. This picture speaks 1,000 words.
1. Geoff Whiten is new GMG chairman. Each person on stage got a very literal song to accompany them, eg outgoing chair Valerie McBride-Munro had 'Valerie' by Amy Winehouse. Whiten got 'Hi Ho Silver Lining'. Because he has a grey beard? He's a silverback? He often wins silver at Chelsea?
2. Whiten has asked GMG committee member Martyn Cox to set some long overdue judging standards for next year.
3. Coxy was seen late at night arm wrestling Gardener's World staff in the Master Gunner pub near the venue after the awards. He was winning. No-one went to the official after 'party' event. I had to leave early to babysit. But not before...
4. James Wong spoke to me in the Master Gunner. A nice guy. Won an award for his Grow Your Own Drugs. I said he'd won Cox's much talked about alternative awards most fanciable male because my colleague Magda Ibrahim had voted multiply. Said we'd checked his ethnobotany credentials and they stood up, disappointingly. Wong looked a little bemused.
5. The GMG awards are now run by a little-known magazine. Rather like Rodney Bewes running the Oscars. Or more like a Brookside extra running the Welsh Baftas.
6. When James Alexander-Sinclair won blog of the year he expounded the virtues of blogging as the way ahead. Amateur Gardening's Tim Rumball exclaimed loudly-'bollocks'. JAS does make most of his cash from picture-led features in national gardening mags.
7. Alys Fowler said I always wear bad shoes. I took one off and showed her the vegetarian shoe label. Alys was fishing for compliments about her secondhand orange suede cowboy jacket. Got none from me, other than 'it smells of death'. Mark Gregory said I was chatting her up. Peter Dawson was in checks. At least he didn't have his Mickey Mouse sweatshirt on.
8. Kris Collins won trade writer of the year for a piece in HW. His baby is due next week too.
9. Most popular winners-Wong, Mark Diacono from River Cottage, Wesley Kerr.
10. Most shocking-Carol Warters for a PR stunt on world leaders getting sent some seed packets. Jackie Bennett -an unlikely best columnist. Ken Crowther, not bad sex award but best local radio. The clip played: Essex lady. "I've got a terrible mole problem. They dig up my lawn and I've tried everything blah blah blah." Ken: "They are a difficult problem. There's not much you can do." If this was the best bit then it begs the question...
11. Another radio clip-"What should I plant at this time of year?" Answer: "Look in a seed catalogue or your local garden centre." Thanks. Does gardening work on radio?
12. Lose friends and alienate award. http://alturl.com/cbbw. Victoria's Backyard blog said I should have won an award and that papers used my story, only The Independent didn't, or something. I said the Indie is too skint to pay for it's own stories or for writers to write them, thinking Victoria was a standard gardening blogger who didn't know about this stuff. Seems she is night editor for the Independent. Oops.
13. Newsround's John Craven was there and took a gong. For a piece on bees. Or beez as he calls them-his teeth don't fit. I asked Craven if I could present the new Kid's Countryfile.
14. Alan Titchmarsh (on stage to collect best young garden hack), Joe Swift (presenter Andy McIndoe (who gave me the lowdown on the give her an ironing board for xmas story) made a gag about Patch Magic and GroSure for baldness), Alys Fowler, Toby Buckland (won green award for TV peat piece in which you could see producers operating strings attached to Buckland's anorak hood), Eric Robson (a Cumbrian hero)-they were all there. but no Carol Klein, who usually is good fun. The afternoon event climaxed with Peter Beales winning a lifetime acheivement award and was presented with a David Austin bouquet.
15. Seriously, I've been asked to give input on how to improve the awards. This is what I told the organisers.
1. The judging process needs to be transparent with who is judging what and on what criteria made clear.2. The judges of writing awards need journalistic qualifications which need to be listed and matched to the awards they judge.
3. The awards should not be run by a magazine. This year it was like Rodney Bewes running the Oscars. Or an extra from Brookside running the Welsh Baftas. Stop me if you think you've heard this one before.
4. The comments related to winners don’t help-eg 'an original story', 'shows knowledge of the subject matter'.
5. Supporting material was not sent to judges. So if a story reaches national/international prominence and the entrant shows this, it should be considered. The context of a piece needs to be considered by judges, especially if the judges don’t know the context and influence a piece has, as they don’t seem to.
This year's judges: But who judged what?
Stephen Anderton
Heather Barrett-Mold
Matthew Biggs
Stefan Buczacki
Giles Christopher
Graham Clarke
Martyn Cox
Chris Day
Abigail Dodd
Mike Fitt
Clare Foggett
Graeme Gourlay
Jo Gourlay
Anisa Gress
Lucy Halsall
Geoff Hodge
Tony Kirkham
Stephen Lacey
Steve Mitchell
Sally Nex
Steve Ott
Lyndon Parker
Spike Powell
Gordon Rae
Claire Richmond
Tim Rumball
Naomi Slade
Ken Turner
Marc Tyley
Jim Ward
Rosemary Ward
Tamsin Westhorpe
Robin Whitehead
Mike Wyatt
Joanna Yarrow
Tim Young