At Mr Fothergill's plant trials last week in Newmarket the main topics of conversation were the sheer weight of new plants being released on the nation's gardeners - and the appointment of Toby Buckland as Gardener's World lead presenter.
Just as launches of dozens of catalogues by Thompson & Morgan, Mr F, Suttons etc rather confuse the market, there were dozens of potential candidates for the plum Gardener's World job vacated by the ill Monty Don. Not one stood out-just as few of the new plants really look like stars that are set to last.
Toby Buckland got the GW nod after BBC focus groups decided he was right-no idea how they decided this and I doubt anyone else has either other than the those living in BBC-land. Few, even in the industry, have heard of Toby. Gardener's World magazine editor Adam Pasco says Buckland would have been his pick because he doesn't have the ego of Don, Beardshaw etc and is more of a grass roots character than Swift etc. Telegraph writer Ursula Buchan made the not unreasonable point that a woman-Carol Klein-should have been appointed. Carol is unhappy at being overlooked. If I was ex-HW features editor turned GW gardener Alys Fowler I'd be annoyed too. Ditto Joe Swift.
It's a bit like the seed companies saying their new plant launches are better than tried and tested old ones - the Beeb is saying is there current crop of presenters aren't as good as a nobody.